In the past few weeks Chris Pirillo has taken a beating over his need to revert back to Windows XP. I don’t understand why this seems to affect so many people’s lives with such intensity. When I first read the article he posted about his desire to move back to Windows XP, I was just more curious than anything.
I have had my fare share of frustrations with Windows Vista and hardware compatibility as well. I first installed Vista to test out the Media Center capabilities and was quite frustrated at the lack of driver support for my system. In the end I decided to revert back to XP MCE because it worked much better. I didn’t give this much thought however, MCE has always been a bit of a pain to setup when you do it on your own so I thought the same issues might be plaguing be even though I was up a version.
Since then I have decided to try installing it on desktops and laptops and have more recently been pleasantly surprised at how well it supports most hardware. I have installed it on IBM T43’s, Dell D420’s, Dell D620s and an HP d530. All have worked out of the box. The issues I now face are with the simplest of things. For instance my most recent frustration is with Windows Movie Maker in Vista. The simplest things seem to go wrong; when adding transitions to my films I am unable to play back the preview. No errors appear but I found a forum post stating that if you increase the amount of shared memory for video/RAM to 224 MB or more then it should work. To me this is a huge shortfall. I was excited to be able to use the new features of Vista MM (like DVD creation) and now I am stuck back with XP as it’s all that works.
This type of thing may sound trivial to some. But that’s simply because that feature or software is not something that you find important. In the end we all have things that we find are priorities and the fact that I don’t use it shouldn’t reflect the need to make it functional.
Another thing that I am upset about is the misnomer that you can run a software in Windows XP SP2 compatibility mode. It’s not true compatibility mode, it’s run it like the Windows XP kernel but if you need a feature that was changed in Vista (such as the aforementioned help section) then you are up a tree.
Not that I think MS or Vista are bad; however I think that there was a definite lack of communication between MS, the hardware manufacturers and software creators. This is something that MS seemed to manage with the release of Windows XP. At the time XP was released I was working for a hardware manufacturer, not one of the top echelon; irregardless because we were part of the MS Partner program they were in contact with us. We came out with product drivers before the release of XP because of that interaction.
Like Chris, I am a long time MS product user and even though I dabble in other operating systems (mainly Linux in the flavour of Ubuntu). I am more disappointed that I can’t use Vista the way it was designed because it looks exciting.